What comprises a Mint Julep is simple: bourbon, sugar, spearmint, and lots of shaved ice. Simple as the list of ingredients is, a lot of thought and care go into making one of these glorious drinks. For you history buffs, the Mint Julep first appeared in print in a book by John Davis called Travels of Four Years and a Half in the United States of America. Published in London in 1803, it describes the Mint Julep as “a dram of spirituous liquor that has mint steeped in it, taken by Virginians of a morning.” The term “steeping” here has divided julep tipplers over the last two centuries. Traditionalists, whose sole use of mint is adding a sprig as an important olfactory garnish, would probably pooh-pooh any form of steeping, including the way we make ours, as we like to gently muddle mint leaves in the simple syrup before adding ice and bourbon. But we say, the more mint, the merrier. If you just want your nose to be tickled by the redolence of fresh mint as your lips touch the glass (or in some instances, a metal julep cup, which keeps the drink frosty cold), then we applaud your choice. If you want to double the amount and substitute pineapple mint, we applaud your choice as well. We find that solely living your life under the rubric of “Tradition,” although important to understand and learn from, can crush the spirit.
And speaking of spirits, the bourbon you choose is probably the most important aspect of the drink. (Yes, the drink must be made with bourbon, but if you want to buck tradition and use rye, we will support your endeavor. Canadian whisky? . . . now you’re pushing it. This is an American invention after all.) Bourbons range widely in flavor and proof. Try Jim Beam at 80 proof and see how that holds up to Buffalo Trace, whose proof is 90. Both work equally well, but you may want to adjust how much simple syrup and mint you put in. Remember, the choice is yours, gentle reader. The goal here is to sit back on the veranda, or terrace, or wherever it is you like to tipple on a warm spring day, and smell the mint as you sip to your heart’s content.